Capitalism for Good: Andrea Masterson on Building Businesses That Lift Up Their Communities

Most of us have been told that business is a numbers game. Andrea Masterson thinks it can be a community game, too.

Andrea hosts the Capitalism for Good podcast, where she interviews business leaders making a positive impact, and Capitalism for Green, which focuses on community-based refill stores. She also owns Bittersweet Paradox and has spent over 15 years bridging the gap between nonprofit and corporate strategy.

This week on The Chaotic Middle, she shared how burnout, a family crisis, and a lot of curiosity led her to build a business that fits around her life.

From Tryhard to Burnout

Andrea describes herself as a lifelong tryhard. She was the teacher's pet who wanted to be the best student and the best athlete, and she mostly wanted to beat her own previous best. She graduated from college early, planning to go to law school. Then she realized a bureaucratic path wouldn't let her change kids' lives the way she wanted.

She turned to nonprofit work instead, drawing on years of organizing volunteer events. Each job started with excitement and ended with leadership that didn't feel right.

She pivoted again and again, working as a freelance copywriter, a consultant, and in restaurants. She also managed infectious disease, cancer therapeutic, and vaccine development programs through the height of COVID. It was fulfilling work, but it nearly broke her.

"I am burnt out to no end."

When Life Forced a Change

About three years ago, Andrea's dad had a massive stroke. She was living eight hours away, so she began commuting back and forth and working from the hospital. Her father now lives with aphasia and hemiparalysis.

Her workplace did not support her. An HR representative told her she wasn't eligible for FMLA, even though the documents said otherwise. When she called it out, she was told the company needed her. At that point, she mentally quit. It wouldn’t be long before she’d quit for real.

During her break, she noticed what she kept returning to. She was good at building things from the start, but she had never done it entirely on her own. She started consulting, helping nonprofits build stable budgets and timelines, and helping for-profits create community give-backs. Then she realized something.

"Oh, shoot. I'm an entrepreneur now."

A Snowball of Projects

Andrea wanted to learn new skills, so she set out to interview 100 business leaders whose work she admired. That plan snowballed. She decided she wanted to promote those leaders, and she could repurpose the podcast into content for them.

After interviewing a woman who owns a refill shop, she decided to open one herself, built around the Capitalism for Good mission.

Meanwhile, friends kept calling her when life got hard. She started sharing the 10- to 15-minute journaling prompts she uses daily. Those became part of Bittersweet Paradox, which supports the humans behind the business.

Looking back, she realized she had built a business that fits around her life. When her parents and she all got sick in the same few weeks, she took two full days off and nothing fell apart. In her experience, her past “traditional” jobs wouldn’t have given her that option.

What Is a Refill Store?

Many people have never heard of a refill store (myself included!), so Andrea explained. You bring your own container, or buy one there, and refill it with products like shampoo. Many products are cleaner, with fewer ingredients that irritate skin and pollute waterways, and you don’t add more single-use packaging to the environment.

"It's not going to fix everything in the world, but it is something."

This ties into why she put "capitalism" in her project names. For-profit companies can create waste as a cost of doing business, while nonprofits step in to clean it up. Andrea wonders what would happen if both put their skills toward not creating the problem to begin with.

The Real Story About Small Business Survival

Capitalism for Good features 100 interviews with business leaders who make a positive impact. Andrea focuses on the how and the why. How did they get there, and how can others replicate it? She ends each episode by asking guests who else deserves a shout-out. That question has created a domino effect of introductions and friendships.

She also made a striking observation. About 20 to 25% of small businesses close in their first year, over half within five years, and roughly 70% within ten. Andrea has completed 66 interviews so far, and not a single business has closed.

"If you put small business ownership that focuses on community, that seems to be a really powerful lesson for all of us to learn."

Finding Community in Hard Seasons

Andrea and I talked about how sharing hard experiences creates connection. I shared my own story about posting online after an ectopic pregnancy. I had no idea how many people were watching until they reached out.

Andrea has seen the same thing. People often DM months later to say a post meant something to them.

She also spoke honestly about caregiving. Looking after a parent is a team effort, and navigating the hospital system can feel like flying blind. Resources exist, but they are hard to find. She offers to point people in the right direction if they reach out.

"It's not like it takes away all of the sadness. It's just a little boost of, okay, I'm not in this alone."

When her dad had his stroke, a close family friend showed up and walked the family through what to expect. She made dinner, watched the dog, and had a movie ready when they got home. Andrea says she will never forget it and tries to show up for others the same way.

Dream Guests and Business Models That Inspire

When I asked about her dream guests, Andrea named Jesse Cole of the Savannah Bananas and leaders at Patagonia. She admires businesses that put community first. She shared one example of a sustainable brand owner who decided not to launch a sunscreen line. Instead, she publicly pointed customers to companies she trusts.

She would also love to interview the parks and recreation director from the city where she grew up. His department turned plots of land into green spaces, sports fields, and walking paths. That is the kind of third space we both feel is disappearing.

Answering the Chaotic Questions

At the end of every episode, I ask each guest the same three questions.

If you could go back in time and talk to your 2005 self, what would you say to her?

This is such a hard question, and I've heard you ask this of other people, and I'm always like, what would I say? Especially because “okay, well if that hadn't happened, I wouldn't have gotten here...” but I think if I could just give myself a little pep talk: lean into yourself. Trust your own brain. You got this. And also maybe don't take life so seriously.”

A woman comes to you for advice, whether she's a new mom, a new business owner, or a new caregiver. What's the first thing you tell her?

Take a deep breath. Pause. It is going to be very hard, and it's going to be scary, and it's going to have a lot of emotions, but you can do this again. And maybe I would say the exact same thing: lean into yourself and then find the things that maybe you're not the expert at. Find the expert, and find the expert that's in your friend circle. Find those people and lean into them as well.

What do you hope people remember about you from this time period?

I care. I truly believe that we can all make this a little bit better if we work together.

Where to Find Andrea

You can find Capitalism for Good and Capitalism for Green wherever you listen to podcasts. Andrea shares on Instagram, where you can DM her about Bittersweet Paradox or community give-back initiatives. She donates 10% of profits from her podcasts and Bittersweet Paradox to a rotating monthly charity. 

Good Things Are Happening Out There

Good things are happening in our communities, even when headlines say otherwise. If this conversation lifted your spirits, share it with someone who could use some good news today.

If you want to hear more stories about incredible women doing incredible things, check out The Chaotic Middle anywhere you listen to podcasts, including:

Amanda Russell

I write content to get you noticed and copy to get you sales. My clients are entrepreneurs, small businesses, and nonprofits working to make the world a better, more inclusive place.

https://www.chaoscoordinationllc.com
Next
Next

Making Sense of Money with Melissa Mittelstaedt